presents
WebMD Community Talk Show
Serving up a new debate daily, this is the place where putting up your dukes and defending your opinion is encouraged.
Photoshopped Beauty: Yes or No?
Olivia_WebMD_Staff posted:
Actress Cate Blanchett recently posed for a non-retouched cover shot for Intelligent Life magazine.
In a world where we all compare ourselves to a very unrealistic ideal of beauty, do you find this refreshing?
How do you think the trend of airbrushing and computer retouching of photos in the media and in ads affects how we see ourselves and others?
In a world where we all compare ourselves to a very unrealistic ideal of beauty, do you find this refreshing?
How do you think the trend of airbrushing and computer retouching of photos in the media and in ads affects how we see ourselves and others?
6 Replies |Watch This Discussion | Report This| Share this:Photoshopped Beauty: Yes or No?Actress Cate Blanchett recently posed for a <a rel="nofollow" href="http://thelook.today.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/03/21/10796953-cate-blanchett-goes-sans-photoshop-for-magazine-cover">non-retouched cover shot </a> for <i>Intelligent Life</i> magazine. <br /><br />In a world where we all compare ourselves to a very unrealistic ideal of beauty, do you find this refreshing? <br /><br />How do you think the trend of airbrushing and computer retouching of photos in the media and in ads affects how we see ourselves and others?
Rohvannyn responded:
I do find it refreshing. People can be beautiful all on their own, especially if they eat right and take care of their bodies. Adjusting the ideals of what is beautiful can help tremendously too. Photoshop is fun but shouldn't be overused, because folks hold themselves up to to that type of standard and shouldn't need to.
Report This| Share this:Photoshopped Beauty: Yes or No?I do find it refreshing. People can be beautiful all on their own, especially if they eat right and take care of their bodies. Adjusting the ideals of what is beautiful can help tremendously too. Photoshop is fun but shouldn't be overused, because folks hold themselves up to to that type of standard and shouldn't need to.
3point14 responded:
I prefer to see air brushing in magazines and ads and stuff. I see enough reality when I leave my house, I buy stuff like Cosmo for entertainment, not to see more of what I see at Wal-Mart.
I don't compare myself to those images because there is no comparison. I do too much in my day to day to be perfectly coiffed and made-up, it isn't my job to look good. I'd never compare a friend of mine to a model, because my friends just aren't models. Not that they're not beautiful, but again, we all have lives to lead that don't include personal trainers, personal chefs, and a manicurist on our staff.
I don't compare myself to those images because there is no comparison. I do too much in my day to day to be perfectly coiffed and made-up, it isn't my job to look good. I'd never compare a friend of mine to a model, because my friends just aren't models. Not that they're not beautiful, but again, we all have lives to lead that don't include personal trainers, personal chefs, and a manicurist on our staff.
Report This| Share this:Photoshopped Beauty: Yes or No?I prefer to see air brushing in magazines and ads and stuff. I see enough reality when I leave my house, I buy stuff like Cosmo for entertainment, not to see more of what I see at Wal-Mart.<br /> <br />I don't compare myself to those images because there is no comparison. I do too much in my day to day to be perfectly coiffed and made-up, it isn't my job to look good. I'd never compare a friend of mine to a model, because my friends just aren't models. Not that they're not beautiful, but again, we all have lives to lead that don't include personal trainers, personal chefs, and a manicurist on our staff.
Very good point, but people were quite beautiful in magazines etc even before airbrushing etc got popular. I do agree however that even then they had trainers and makeup artists etc etc etc to help them look prettier than the average person. All I'm saying is there are plenty of folks with natural beauty (including the girls gracing our magazine covers) and that all the retouching isn't, to me, completely necessary.
Report This| Share this:Photoshopped Beauty: Yes or No?Very good point, but people were quite beautiful in magazines etc even before airbrushing etc got popular. I do agree however that even then they had trainers and makeup artists etc etc etc to help them look prettier than the average person. All I'm saying is there are plenty of folks with natural beauty (including the girls gracing our magazine covers) and that all the retouching isn't, to me, completely necessary.
You're right, hahaha the people who don't fit traditional "beauty" aren't in the magazines anyway, so it's really just the airbrushing of the already beautiful...how weird.
Then again, I'm also someone who really likes tattoos, piercings, hair dye, all those kinds of things. For me, I find it "beautiful"/"appealling" when something has an element of unreality to it. When I see someone who's unreasonably pretty, almost a caricature of beauty, I definitely notice it more. If the purpose of the media is to sell itself, a product, or the person on the cover of the magazine, that tends to be what makes me part with my money, at least.
I believe that the message that even a gorgeous, healthy-looking, in shape woman needs an airbrush sends a crappy message to the consumer. But that being said, I think more people would be cultivating their own beauty ideal seperate from what media considers "attractive".
Then again, I'm also someone who really likes tattoos, piercings, hair dye, all those kinds of things. For me, I find it "beautiful"/"appealling" when something has an element of unreality to it. When I see someone who's unreasonably pretty, almost a caricature of beauty, I definitely notice it more. If the purpose of the media is to sell itself, a product, or the person on the cover of the magazine, that tends to be what makes me part with my money, at least.
I believe that the message that even a gorgeous, healthy-looking, in shape woman needs an airbrush sends a crappy message to the consumer. But that being said, I think more people would be cultivating their own beauty ideal seperate from what media considers "attractive".
Report This| Share this:Photoshopped Beauty: Yes or No?You're right, hahaha the people who don't fit traditional "beauty" aren't in the magazines anyway, so it's really just the airbrushing of the already beautiful...how weird.<br /> <br />Then again, I'm also someone who really likes tattoos, piercings, hair dye, all those kinds of things. For me, I find it "beautiful"/"appealling" when something has an element of unreality to it. When I see someone who's unreasonably pretty, almost a caricature of beauty, I definitely notice it more. If the purpose of the media is to sell itself, a product, or the person on the cover of the magazine, that tends to be what makes me part with my money, at least.<br /> <br />I believe that the message that even a gorgeous, healthy-looking, in shape woman needs an airbrush sends a crappy message to the consumer. But that being said, I think more people would be cultivating their own beauty ideal seperate from what media considers "attractive".
Dollbug responded:
Hello Olivia....MiMi in NC....I am normally on the FM board....but I did want to check in and say something about this...
Photoshopped is a Hollywood Illusion....anyone can be made "beautiful" on the outside...by photoshopped touches....it is interesting that people sometimes only "see" the outside of a person....which is only part of them to begin with...and as the old saying goes....beauty is in the eye of the beholder....so what a person "sees" it just that....there is much more to a person than their looks....I have always heard...NEVER judge a book by its cover....
Now...I will also share this with everyone....I have 3 children...all grown now...1 daughter and 2 sons....when my daughter was 13....I sent her to a "beauty school"....for 12 weeks....I drove 2 hours one way and window shopped while she was in this school...learning how to "enhance" herself....she learned how to apply her makeup....which looks very natural, she learned how to do her hair...she learned how to be poised and she transformed into a "little lady".....right in front of me....I was amazed that these people could teach a young girl so much....this was the best money that I have ever spent....she learned how to do the things that young girls should be taught at this age....her education has stayed with her...and she will be 32 years old this year....
The men and women who go to Hollywood....and those who we see in movies and on run ways....are only people...just like the rest of the world....they have just learned how to apply themselves in a different way....it is a process....just like anything else in the world is...
I bet we would all be quite shocked to see just how these people look in person....instead of on the screen...
Interesting topic....
MiMi
Photoshopped is a Hollywood Illusion....anyone can be made "beautiful" on the outside...by photoshopped touches....it is interesting that people sometimes only "see" the outside of a person....which is only part of them to begin with...and as the old saying goes....beauty is in the eye of the beholder....so what a person "sees" it just that....there is much more to a person than their looks....I have always heard...NEVER judge a book by its cover....
Now...I will also share this with everyone....I have 3 children...all grown now...1 daughter and 2 sons....when my daughter was 13....I sent her to a "beauty school"....for 12 weeks....I drove 2 hours one way and window shopped while she was in this school...learning how to "enhance" herself....she learned how to apply her makeup....which looks very natural, she learned how to do her hair...she learned how to be poised and she transformed into a "little lady".....right in front of me....I was amazed that these people could teach a young girl so much....this was the best money that I have ever spent....she learned how to do the things that young girls should be taught at this age....her education has stayed with her...and she will be 32 years old this year....
The men and women who go to Hollywood....and those who we see in movies and on run ways....are only people...just like the rest of the world....they have just learned how to apply themselves in a different way....it is a process....just like anything else in the world is...
I bet we would all be quite shocked to see just how these people look in person....instead of on the screen...
Interesting topic....
MiMi
Report This| Share this:Photoshopped Beauty: Yes or No?<b>Hello Olivia....MiMi in NC....I am normally on the FM board....but I did want to check in and say something about this...</b><br /><b></b> <br /><b>Photoshopped is a Hollywood Illusion....anyone can be made "beautiful" on the outside...by photoshopped touches....it is interesting that people sometimes only "see" the outside of a person....which is only part of them to begin with...and as the old saying goes....beauty is in the eye of the beholder....so what a person "sees" it just that....there is much more to a person than their looks....I have always heard...NEVER judge a book by its cover....</b><br /><b></b> <br /><b>Now...I will also share this with everyone....I have 3 children...all grown now...1 daughter and 2 sons....when my daughter was 13....I sent her to a "beauty school"....for 12 weeks....I drove 2 hours one way and window shopped while she was in this school...learning how to "enhance" herself....she learned how to apply her makeup....which looks very natural, she learned how to do her hair...she learned how to be poised and she transformed into a "little lady".....right in front of me....I was amazed that these people could teach a young girl so much....this was the best money that I have ever spent....she learned how to do the things that young girls should be taught at this age....her education has stayed with her...and she will be 32 years old this year....</b><br /><b></b> <br /><b>The men and women who go to Hollywood....and those who we see in movies and on run ways....are only people...just like the rest of the world....they have just learned how to apply themselves in a different way....it is a process....just like anything else in the world is...</b><br /><b></b> <br /><b>I bet we would all be quite shocked to see just how these people look in person....instead of on the screen...</b><br /><b></b> <br /><b>Interesting topic....</b><br /><b></b> <br /><b></b> <br /><b>MiMi </b>
WebMD Talk Show
Feel like a friendly debate? Take the gloves off and defend your viewpoint.
Learn More
Related News
Expert Blog
Diagnosis: Reality Check
Putting perspective on health news and names in the spotlight.Read More
Other Great Information
- WebMD News Center Read the latest in health news and features.
- WebMD Newsroom Blog Breaking health news at your fingertips.
- WebMD Reality Check Blog Your daily dose of reality around fun and intriguing health topics.
-
The opinions expressed in WebMD User-generated content areas like communities, reviews, ratings, or blogs are solely those of the User, who may or may not have medical or scientific training. These opinions do not represent the opinions of WebMD. User-generated content areas are not reviewed by a WebMD physician or any member of the WebMD editorial staff for accuracy, balance, objectivity, or any other reason except for compliance with our Terms and Conditions. Some of these opinions may contain information about treatments or uses of drug products that have not been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. WebMD does not endorse any specific product, service, or treatment.
Do not consider WebMD User-generated content as medical advice. Never delay or disregard seeking professional medical advice from your doctor or other qualified healthcare provider because of something you have read on WebMD. You should always speak with your doctor before you start, stop, or change any prescribed part of your care plan or treatment. WebMD understands that reading individual, real-life experiences can be a helpful resource, but it is never a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment from a qualified health care provider. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or dial 911 immediately.
Health Solutions From Our Sponsors
About WebMD Advertise With Us Terms of Use Privacy Policy Sponsor Policy Site Map Careers Contact Us
First Aid WebMD Magazine WebMD Health Record WebMD Mobile Newsletters Dictionary Physician Directory
©2005-2013 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved.
WebMD does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See additional information.