Dear selbyerica: Generally there is no statistical difference in pregnancy rates after the removal of either type of IUD. One particularly good study randomly assigned women to one of the two types of IUD, then followed the time to pregnancy after the IUDs were removed.
In this study, time to conception after Copper T removal was 3 months and 4 months for the Mirena (Belhadj, 1986).
It is important to note that the women in these studies had had prior pregnancies thus known fertility.In a retrospective study of 2269 women (Hassan, 2004), 82 women used a non-hormonal IUD and 13 used the Mirena. Compared to women using condoms, the time to pregnancy in non-hormonal IUD users was twice as long.
The Mirena users had the same time to pregnancy (about 4 months) as condom users.
Finally, here is a study with larger numbers and actual pregnancy outcomes:
Contraception. 1992 Dec;46(6):575-84
Return to fertility after removal of a levonorgestrel-releasing intrauterine device and Nova-T.
Andersson K, Batar I, Rybo G.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, East Hospital, University of G?teborg, Sweden.
In a European randomized multicenter study, the efficacy and safety of an intrauterine contraceptive device releasing 20 microgram levonorgestrel/24 hours (LNG-IUD) have been evaluated and compared to the Nova-T. Because the LNG-IUD has a strongly suppressive effect on the endometrium and in some women affects ovarian function, the return to fertility after removal of the IUD was studied. Two-hundred-nine women (71 in the Nova-T and
138 in the LNG-IUD group), who had their IUDs removed because of planning pregnancy, were followed at least 24 months or until termination of pregnancy. For the Nova-T, the cumulative conception gross rate was 71.2/100 women after 12 months (79.7 after 24 months) and for the
LNG-IUD 79.1/100 (86.6 after 24 months). The difference between the devices is not statistically significant, and in spite of the endometrial suppression during use of LNG-IUD, there is no delay of return to fertility and in both groups
96% of the pregnancies occurred during the first year after removal of the device. Eighty-four % of the pregnancies in the Nova-T group and
eighty-six % in the LNG-IUD group ended in live births. The results suggest that the endometrium recovers quickly, normal ovulations are established and the fertility seems to be unaffected after use of an LNG-IUD
selbyerica, if you have had a prior pregnancy with your current partner, I would expect you to conceive before July 2013. If you are over age 30, do not have regular cycles,or have a known obstacle for conception (eg endometriosis), it could take longer. If you have one of these factors I would suggest you see your GYN after six months of unprotected sex. If you are younger and without known obstacles it is reasonable to wait 12 months before starting a fertility work up. Hopefully you will conceive soon.
Yours,
Jane