See All
Preferences
My Communities
My Discussions
My Email Digests
It is obvious that you do not feel comfortable with this test. Go and get tested using a blood sample. Your blood is not going to "react" to some other antigen that the Orasure did not have or the fact that you ran the swab over your gums more than once.
Gail
I understand what you are saying. I do not feel comfortable with this test at all. I do not feel comfortable with it because even though antibodies can be found in every single body fluid of an infected person, it seems as though the concentration in oral fluid is quite low. I also do not understand how the antibodies even get into the oral fluid which leaves me kind of skeptical. Also, I am kind of nervous because the oral test resembles a pregnancy test and during my days in college I have learned that if you stick a pregnancy test in water....you get a negative result by default because water does not have the pregnancy hormones in it. I guess what I am getting at is....can this test be tricked. Would you get a negative result if you stuck the test in water, would you get a negative if actual saliva instead of oral fluid got on the test, would you get a negative result if you swab your tongue instead of your gums? Or does test only work if you got the right specimen on it? Does it know that oral fluid is on the strip and will it not work at all if anything other than what is supposed to be on the strip is on there?
As far as the antigen situation is concerned. I read an article on medscape that stated that an individual arrived at a hospital because he was sick. He was tested with the oral test three times and received a negative result each time BUT when they did an ELISA and Western Blot HIV infection was confirmed. On his Western Blot, there was a weak reaction to gp41 antigen but a strong reaction to gp160 antigen. It was stated that the reason why the oral test was inaccurate was because the Oraquick Advance relies on a single antigen....the gp41 and people with late stage infection have a weak reaction to this particular antigen. This is why I am concerned because it seems as though you can react to different types of antigen. Could you please explain this? There is also the question of faulty equipment. What if the equipment was expired, stored at the wrong temperature, or was just defective....would it still work and give you a negative result. I am just trying to make sure that this test is full proof. I am aware that nothing in this world is 100% but I just do not want to be walking around with the notion that I am okay when I am really not. It seems like this particular test causes a lot of anxiety, not only with myself but with so many others as well. There are two many limitations with this test. Even the fact that they approved it for home use. It is stated that this test is less sensitive because of consumer error. Humans are Humans and can make the same errors whether they are trained or not. I am not saying that is cannot happen with any other test but it is very, very, very rare that you here of someone testing negative with a blood test in a clinical setting outside the window period and then find later that it was a false negative. With this test....it has happened on a more than rare occasion. I am just scared out of mind to the point that my life has been consumed with this situation. I thought I was doing that right thing by getting tested but now I feel like I never did and I am still unsure of my status, unsure of whether I am going live or die a horrible death because I took the wrong type of test. I guess quick and fast doesn't always mean accurate.
Folks with end stage HIV (i.e., AIDS) have immune systems that have been severely damaged by the virus and will often not be able to produce antibodies to any infection or test. This is what kills them; not the actual virus but rather infections they cannot fight off at the end stage of this disease.
This has nothing to do with you. If you were late stage HIV you would be presenting with some very severe symptoms (I'm assuming you are not experiencing such things as significant weight loss, frequent diarrhea, specific types of pneumonia, sarcoma's, etc..).
Go take a blood test. You are convinced the oral tests are faulty when in truth, they are quite accurate. However, getting a blood test is the only way you will be confident of your status.
Gail
I am trying to get up the nerve to get a blood test. I am just so afraid of the outcome. I have not experienced any of the symptoms that you described. However I have experienced tinea versicolor on my neck and folliculitis on my leg, which prompted me to go a get tested in the first place. I had a CBC done last year and it was normal so I am guessing that if I did in fact have AIDS my blood work would have been abnormal and I would have been experiencing alot more problems than minor skin problems. I was convinced that I was infected because I have never in my life experienced any skin issues before accept acne. I thought once the negative result was read...I would be relieved. Now I am afraid that something went wrong with the test. I guess I feel that way because I have no other explanation for the skin issues. I understand that there other issues in the world besides HIV but when you have been sexually active and you experience wired things...you automatically assume that HIV is the problem. The internet does not help either because every time you look up skin problems...the first thing that pops up is HIV.
I understand that you are saying that the oral HIV test is quite accurate and I am sure that it is. But I am convinced that it is faulty because of people performing it. I sit and ask myself "if the test was designed to look for antibodies....how could it possibly miss them if they were there?" but after reading so many things it seems as though expert have been saying that there is a small margin of error with the oral test and can not explain why. The test is very simple I mean....you are just swabbing your gums for heavens sake how could you possibly mess it up. But people have found away to do so and that's what scares me. I pray to GOD everyday that I will go get this blood test and hear the words "negative" because I have promised myself and GOD that I will never put myself through this ever again. Thank you so much for listening to me and God Bless you.
Tinea versicolor is a very common fungal infection on the skin. My own partner has this; it flares up in the summer as we live in a hot humid part of the country (Georgia), then fades away in the cooler winter months. He certainly isn't HIV positive and he's had this for as long as I've known him (way over a decade). If he was HIV positive he'd likely be dead by now and I'd be infected.
You can't jump to the conclusion that you must be positive because of these "symptoms" which have nothing to do with HIV. Accept your oral test results or go get tested, get the negative result and put your concerns behind you and then you can stop worrying about all of this.
Gail
I am trying very hard to accept the oral swab results the only reason that I am having a hard time accepting it is because of articles that I read that clearly state that this test seems to miss infections. You can find one of the articles on www.thebody.com. There is an article by an HIV specialist by the name of David Pilcher who conducted a private study and found the oral test only detected 86% of infections....most were acute infections but some were not. I am very afraid that I am one of these people. You also say go and get a blood test and get my negative result like it is definite that I will get a negative result. There are to many facts out there concerning this test stating that it is not all that reliable. If it were, there would be no conflicts or contradictory about it. I am extremely frightened and confused about what the blood test will say because of the information is out there about this test. People keep saying that it is FDA approved and if it were not reliable they would not use it...but what people are not understanding is that the FDA and the people from Orasure are not the ones conducting the test. Ordinary people who take a training class are the ones giving the test and from what I understand, it seems that every single clinic is trained differently. So you have all these people out there that may or may not have the wrong results. I am not understanding why this is being allowed or why the test is still even offered. I even heard a nurse say "those are not real HIV and should not be taken seriously" When I asked her why she said that...she stated "everyone knows that HIV is a disease that affects the blood so what makes them think that you can test for it any other way". I almost used the bathroom on myself in fear when she said this because it made since. No one has yet to explain how they are testing for HIV through your mouth. Yes, I understand that the test is looking for antibodies....but how do they get there and are they definitely there? I am just scared senseless right now and have even considered ending my life. I just wish that I knew for sure that I was negative without having to take another test.
It is me again...okay so I took your advice and I went to give a sample of blood. It was a finger prick test called "clearview complete" Yay me. It was negative...however, I still have a concern and I would gladly except your and any other professionals expertise on this matter. Okay, here goes...the persona who performed my test pricked my finger and slightly squeezed my finger to get a blood sample, he did not wipe away the first drop of blood, he used the first one. I now have read that you are not supposed to squeeze the finger due to the possibility of excess tissue fluid and that you are supposed to wipe away the first drop of blood. Do you know how these minor details affect the test results??? Please help me because I am tired of living this nightmare. Thank you
You have to accept the very good news that you are HIV negative and just let these worries about being positive drop.
Gail
Women's Health Newsletter
Find out what women really need.
Helpful Tips
- Coping With Anxiety & HIV Worry
- A few words of advice that you can choose to take to heart
- Nutrition and HIV/AIDS
Helpful Resources
Related News
Related Drug Reviews
- Drug Name User Reviews
Report Problems to the
Food and Drug Administration
You are encouraged to report negative side effects of prescription drugs to the FDA. Visit the FDA MedWatch website or call 1-800-FDA-1088.
Other HIV/AIDS Information
More Related Communities
The opinions expressed in WebMD User-generated content areas like communities, reviews, ratings, or blogs are solely those of the User, who may or may not have medical or scientific training. These opinions do not represent the opinions of WebMD. User-generated content areas are not reviewed by a WebMD physician or any member of the WebMD editorial staff for accuracy, balance, objectivity, or any other reason except for compliance with our Terms and Conditions. Some of these opinions may contain information about treatments or uses of drug products that have not been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. WebMD does not endorse any specific product, service, or treatment.
Do not consider WebMD User-generated content as medical advice. Never delay or disregard seeking professional medical advice from your doctor or other qualified healthcare provider because of something you have read on WebMD. You should always speak with your doctor before you start, stop, or change any prescribed part of your care plan or treatment. WebMD understands that reading individual, real-life experiences can be a helpful resource, but it is never a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment from a qualified health care provider. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or dial 911 immediately.
Health Solutions From Our Sponsors
©2005-2013 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved.
WebMD does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See additional information.


